Crossword clues for I can't believe _____... 4 lettersAnswerClueINMEShe Believes ___ (Kenny Rogers song)UMNOCan't believe you thought that would flyIATE...believe ___ the whole thing!GAELBeliever in the Otherworld, in olden timesSIKHOne believing in the Three Pillars of contemplating God's names, working diligently, and sharing with othersIBETThat's definitely believableFEELBelieveTALEIt's not to be believedLEOSFolks who love the limelight, if you believe any of that supernatural stuffIBETYou expect me to believe that?!YEAHLike I believe thatRICHHard to believePISHCome on, don't believe that!SECTYou can believe in itINMEShe Believes __INMEKenny Rogers's "She Believes __"SHAMMake-believeNILEPtolemy believed the Mountains of the Moon was its sourceSHIAThey believe that Ali is the true successor to MuhammadJAINBeliever in a Hindu creed that espouses respect for every living organismANKHSymbol that some believe to be derived from the shape of a bull vertebraAVERShow that one believesELISDon't believe themIKIDYou didn't really believe that, did you?RIDEWith 58-Across, give "Believe" singer a hard time?IMAMOne of the twelve in which the Twelver Shi'ites believeFIBSThey're hard to believeJAINBeliever in the nonviolent principle of "ahimsa"BUYSCompletely believesMETSYa Gotta Believe teamASIFWho's going to believe that?SAHLWho said "A conservative is someone who believes in reform. But not now"ISMSYou'd better believe themADIASarah McLachlan single with the lyrics "I do believe I've failed you"TALLHard to believeCHERBelieve Grammy winnerISISGoddess believed to be from the Nile DeltaEELSAnimals that Aristotle believed were spontaneously generatedHAHAI can't believe you fell for thatOMFGCan u BELIEVE dis?!?!WARYNot readily believingWHOAThis I can't believe!SIKHBeliever who sounds like they're searching?AMENThat's what I believeSHIABelievers in the Fourteen InfalliblesCHERBelieve singerHELDBelievedIKIDDon't believe a word of itEVILIt is a sin to believe _____ of others, but it is seldom a mistake (H.L. Mencken)ITORBelieve ___ not!